The Politics of Democratisation: Creating an Independent Communications Regulator in Transitional Taiwan

Doctoral thesis English OPEN
Chen, Ya-Chi

This thesis examines the creation of the National Communications Commission (NCC), an independent media regulatory agency in Taiwan, in order to shed light on the relationship between media, state, and democracy in post-transition countries. This study positions the NCC as the key transformation of media reform during the political transition to democracy. On the one hand, it addresses the role of media in transitional societies and how political and industry power elites try to maintain control. On the other hand, it traces the rise of the ‘regulatory state’, a global trend towards regulatory reform, and investigates how the political environment in transitional countries may influence its development. This research is based on the analysis of case studies spanning issues of institutional legitimacy, media ownership, and convergence legislation, with the support of data collected by document analysis and interviews with actors in the policymaking process.\ud \ud The findings point to how Taiwan’s post-authoritarian political background has outweighed economic and technological factors as described in mainstream literature in giving rise to the creation of the agency. The analysis demonstrates that state intervention and politicised concepts of democratisation and independence of the agency both impair media regulatory capacities in transitional societies. More importantly, it is indicated that the threat to democracy has been shifting from authoritarian states to unfettered markets where concentration of media ownership and impediments to media reform through entrenched politico-economic networks have taken place. I question the popular discourse that democratisation is equal to the withdrawal of the state in media regulation, calling instead for active civic engagement to hold the agency accountable, scrutinise its performance, and make the media better serve the public.
  • References (22)
    22 references, page 1 of 3

    Chapter 4 The emergence of the NCC ...................................................................... 74  Technological Advancement .............................................................................................74  Global Economic Marketisation ........................................................................................79  Political Transformation .................................................................................................... 85  Political democratisation ..............................................................................................86  Administrative modernisation: the Government Re-Engineering Project ....................91  Change of government: fuel to politicisation ................................................................97  Conclusion .......................................................................................................................110

    Hsu,  M.‐J.  &  Liu,  L.‐R.  (2009)  'Academia  and  media  reform  groups  denounce  WWCT's censure of NCC,' Liberty Times, 05 June. 

    Hsueh,  M.‐J.  (2009a)  'KMT  lawmakers:  unqualified  NCC  commissioner  should  Resign,' Commercial Times, 02 June. 

    Jakubowicz,  K.  (1995)  'Media  within  and  without  the  state:  press  freedom  in  Eastern Europe,' Journal of Communication, 45 (4), 125‐139. 

    Jakubowicz,  K.  (2002)  'Media  in  transition:  the  case  of  Poland,'  in  Price,  M.,  Rozumilowicz,  B.  &  Verhulst,  S.  (eds.)  Media  Reform:  Democratizing  the  Media, Democratizing the State. London: Routledge. 

    Jessop,  B.  (2006)  'The  state  and  state‐building,'  in  Rhodes,  R.,  Bindes,  S.  &  Rockman,  B.  (eds.)  The Oxford Handbook of Political Institutions.  Oxford: 

    Johnson,  O.  (1998)  'The  media  and  democracy  in  Eastern  Europe,'  in  O'neil,  P.  (ed.)  Communicating  Democracy:  the  Media  and  Political  Transitions. 

    Majone,  G.  (1999)  'The  regulatory  state  and  its  legitimacy  problems,'  West  European Politics, 22 (1), 1‐24. 

    Manzetti, L. (2000) 'The political economy of regulatory policy,' in Manzetti, L.  (ed.)  Regulatory  Policy  in  Latin  America:  Post‐Privatization  Realities. 

    Mao,  C.‐k.  (2007)  On  the  function  of  Communications  Management  Act.  in  Business  Today  (ed.)  Syposium  on  Reviewing  Communications  Management Act Taipei: Business Today. 

  • Metrics
    0
    views in OpenAIRE
    0
    views in local repository
    87
    downloads in local repository

    The information is available from the following content providers:

    From Number Of Views Number Of Downloads
    Goldsmiths Research Online - IRUS-UK 0 87
Share - Bookmark